Generative search (AI Overviews, answer engines, and chatbot-style discovery) is changing what “search success” looks like. For the last decade, most SEO and paid search teams optimised for clicks. Now, the interface itself is doing more of the explaining, comparing, and shortlisting before a user ever lands on your site.
That usually means lower traffic. But it can also mean better lead quality because the people who still click, call, or submit a form are arriving after a deeper pre-qualification step happened inside the search experience.
The shift is not theoretical. Multiple data points show users clicking less when AI summaries appear and when “zero-click” behaviour increases. Pew Research found that when an AI summary appears, users click traditional search results in 8% of visits vs 15% when no AI summary appears.
SparkToro reported that in 2024, 58.5% of US Google searches and 59.7% of EU searches resulted in zero clicks.
So if clicks go down, why can lead quality go up? Because generative search changes
What changes inside the funnel
Traditional search often brought mixed intent. A user might click three blogs, bounce, and return later. Generative search compresses those steps. The AI summary:
- Clarifies the problem (definitions, symptoms, “what it means”).
- Introduces options (categories, approaches, trade-offs).
- Sets expectations (pricing ranges, timelines, limitations).
- Pre-screens trust (cites sources, highlights brands, compares).
That matters because a lead is “high-quality” when they have clear need + right fit + readiness. Generative search tends to filter out “curious browsers” and leave you with users who have moved closer to decision.
Bain’s research describes this “zero-click” reality: about 80% of consumers rely on zero-click results for at least 40% of their searches, reducing organic web traffic by an estimated 15%–25%.
Gartner also predicts a major shift of discovery away from classic search toward AI/chat agents, forecasting a 25% drop in traditional search engine volume by 2026.
Prepare your strategy for generative search - talk to our team today
Lead quality improves because the questions get better
Generative search encourages longer, more specific prompts. Users stop searching like “best CRM” and start searching like:
- “Best CRM for 20-person B2B sales team with HubSpot migration and India GST invoices”
- “Alternative to X that supports SOC2 and SSO under $Y”
- “Which treatment option is safer for my situation?” (high-stakes categories)
The more specific the query, the more likely it represents:
This naturally increases the share of “high-intent” visits among the smaller set of visits you receive.
The lead quality matrix that will matter most
Instead of measuring only sessions and CTR, teams will shift toward a Lead Quality Matrix, how traffic behaves and converts after being pre-educated by AI.
Here’s a practical way to think about it:
Intent type (in generative search) | Typical click likelihood | Typical lead quality | What to optimise for |
Informational (“what is…”, definitions) | Low | Low–Medium | Brand mention + authority, email capture, remarketing |
Comparative (“X vs Y”, “best for…”) | Medium | Medium–High | Comparison pages, proof (case studies), pricing context |
Solution-ready (“vendor for…”, “book demo”, “near me”) | High | High | Conversion UX, fast trust signals, clear next step |
Why this works: AI summaries reduce random clicks at the top of funnel, but they can push the remaining clickers toward mid-to-bottom funnel pages.
Ready for the next phase of search? Let’s optimize for quality leads.
New KPIs: measure “quality per visit,” not “visits per month”
If your traffic drops 20–40% but conversion rate doubles, pipeline may stay flat—or even rise.
Track these metrics weekly by channel and by query cluster:
Lead Quality Score (LQS) components
- ICP Fit Rate: % of leads matching your ideal company size, industry, region, budget.
- Sales Acceptance Rate (SAL): % accepted by sales (or moved to stage 2).
- Time-to-First-Meeting: faster often = clearer intent.
- Demo-to-Opportunity Rate: strongest quality indicator.
- Multi-touch Assist: AI search may create fewer first-click sessions but more “assisted” conversions.
You are basically trying to improve:
Qualified pipeline per 1,000 impressions
not
raw clicks per 1,000 impressions
Concrete examples of how this plays out
Example 1: B2B SaaS (complex product)
A founder searches: “best employee engagement platform for remote team, integrates with Slack, 200 employees, privacy compliant.”
The AI summary compares options, lists constraints, and cites a handful of sources. The founder clicks only one or two vendors, but those visits are heavily pre-qualified.
Result: fewer demo requests, but higher “right fit” demos and fewer time-wasters.
Example 2: Local services
A user asks a generative interface: “best LASIK clinic for high myopia with thin cornea, recovery time, safety.” If the AI summary answers most basics, only serious candidates click clinic sites.
Result: fewer calls, but higher appointment show-up rates
(As a caution: AI summaries can be wrong in sensitive areas; that’s why trust signals and medically reviewed content matter. )
What to do now to win higher-quality leads
- Build “citation-ready” content blocks
AI systems prefer clean, quotable chunks: definitions, steps, comparisons, pros/cons, checklists, and constraints. - Shift from “keyword pages” to “decision pages”
Create pages that answer buying questions: implementation time, pricing model, security, integrations, who it’s best for, who it’s not for. - Strengthen entity authority
Generative search often surfaces brands it understands as entities: consistent positioning, expert authorship, trusted mentions, and clear about pages. - Instrument quality, not just volume
Add CRM fields and routing that capture “why now,” “budget range,” “use case,” “timeline,” and “current solution.” This turns lead quality into measurable data. - Design conversion paths for low-traffic worlds
If clicks are scarcer, every landing experience must be sharp: proof above the fold, instant relevance, short forms, fast scheduling, and clear next step.
Takeaway
Traffic will become a noisier success metric because generative search keeps more users inside the results. That part is already visible in CTR and zero-click studies.
But the teams that adapt will notice something more important: lead quality becomes the new battleground. Generative search pre-educates, pre-screens, and often pre-shortlists.
If your brand shows up in that shortlisting layer and your site is built to convert decision-stage visitors you can lose clicks and still win pipeline.
